Does Barron’s have a point? Or is it simply spreading fear?
In the latest issue, Randall W. Forsyth warns about passing by your local newsstand.
Apparently, there’s an image lurking there that’s the “kiss of death” for the stock market.
It’s so ghastly, in fact, that it prompted the researcher who tracks these appearances to gasp and use the Lord’s name in vain. (Repent!)
Supposedly, the appearance alone means there’s an 80% chance that the current bull market will come to an end within a month.
Now, we’ve made it a habit here to routinely dispel market mistruths.
Case in point: We told you to shrug off the fearmongering in the headlines about September being the worst month for stocks. Why? Because the double-digit rally we witnessed leading up to this month actually pointed to even more gains.
Sure enough, the S&P 500 Index has traded higher in nine out of the last 11 sessions. Total gain for the month so far? A stout 4.4%, compared to the average return the mainstream financial rags told you to expect for the month of negative 1.1%.
Armed with the data, it’s time to dish out the truth again. So here goes…
Warning: Graphic Content
This is the image that should scare you stockless.
It’s the latest cover of TIME Magazine, emblazoned with the iconic Wall Street bull.
As Forsyth says, “The cover of general-interest magazines has been a redoubtable contrarian indicator, since, well, Henry Luce came up with the idea of TIME Magazine in the 1920s.”
Forget the content of the articles, though. (The most recent TIME article isn’t irrationally exuberant.)
According to expert magazine tracker, Paul Macrae Montgomery of Universal Economics, it’s the image that matters most. It carries utmost importance because of the broad message it sends to everyday Americans.
The $100 Trump Retirement Roadmap
Trump is set to unleash a $11.1 trillion tsunami in the markets…
Now that he's officially taken office, dozens of tiny firms could skyrocket by 100%, 300% and even 721%.
This is your chance to turn a small stake of $100… into a life-changing fortune.
Click here to find out how.
In fact, Montgomery told Forsyth, “If historic probabilities reliably forecast the future, there’s an 80% chance the market will top in a month and will be lower a year from now.”
No doubt, that’s what prompted Forsyth to write his most ominous line, “For stock market investors, there is no kiss of death like seeing a bull on the cover of TIME.”
Scared? Don’t be.
It’s Different With TIME
The classic example of the magazine cover indicator is, of course, the August 1979 issue of BusinessWeek. It proclaimed “The Death of Equities.” And then the markets went on to enjoy two decades’ worth of prosperity.
Apparently, Forsyth forgot to ask if the accuracy of the indictor changes with each circulation. Because according to Laszlo Birinyi of Birinyi Associates, things are different when it comes to TIME.
“Over the last 65 years, TIME Magazine has featured the picture of a bull on its cover multiple times,” says Birinyi. “We’ve gone back and pulled the historical TIME Magazine covers and have found that the myth has been mostly incorrect.”
Almost 70% of the time, stocks are actually higher one year later, averaging a return of 12.79%. There’s only been one instance, back in 1948, when the market hit the skids.
So much for that “kiss of death” thing, huh?
Bottom line: Don’t automatically do the opposite of what magazine covers tell you. And shame on Barron’s for suggesting as much. Not long ago, on April 22, its cover featured a bull on a pogo stick and the headline “Dow 16,000!” Yet they weren’t exactly telling investors to bail because of it.
Now, I’m not saying the stock market is guaranteed to go higher from here. Only that nobody knows when it’ll stop for sure. Not even the top brass at magazines who decide on the art and headlines to accompany each issue.
And that means, as always, the best strategy for us is to stay invested and simply mind our protective stops. Period.
Ahead of the tape,